Delphi Consensus on Sickle Cell Disease Clinical Trial Endpoints: Publication Support for The Lancet Haematology

At a Glance

Turacoz, a global scientific communications agency, supported an international Delphi consensus on clinical trial endpoints in sickle cell disease (SCD), from evidence synthesis to publication of the consensus manuscript in The Lancet Haematology.

Background: Why Do Sickle Cell Disease Trials Need Standardized Endpoints?

SCD trials have long faced substantial variability in endpoint selection and the definitions of vaso-occlusive complications (historically described as “vaso-occlusive crisis”), severely limiting cross-trial comparability and the ability to demonstrate treatment efficacy. SCD, which includes sickle cell anemia, is a group of inherited red blood cell disorders marked by recurrent vaso-occlusive complications. Furthermore, recent high-profile clinical trials such as the HOPE trial of voxelotor demonstrated an increase of approximately 1.1 g/dL in hemoglobin levels; the annualized incidence of vaso-occlusive crises showed minimal reduction.1 Similarly, the crizanlizumab STAND trial demonstrated a significant reduction in annual rates of vaso-occlusive crisis, thus failing to achieve the endpoint.2 This highlights an urgent need for standardizing endpoints and trial design for SCD management.

Client Need and Turacoz’s Role

The client partnered with Turacoz, a global scientific communications agency, for end-to-end strategic and publication support, encompassing evidence synthesis, expert meeting coordination, Delphi consensus coordination, comprehensive manuscript development, and journal submission support, including revisions in response to peer-review feedback. The project timeline was 14 months.

Our Approach: How Was the Delphi Consensus Conducted?

The project commenced with a comprehensive assessment of current practices in SCD clinical trials. The Turacoz team conducted an extensive evidence review and developed a detailed evidence deck summarizing recent SCD clinical trials, including study characteristics, endpoint definitions, eligibility criteria, and key results for each study. This evidence base supported the steering committee in defining the scope and objectives of the expert discussions.

An international panel of 15 experts from five continents, comprising the steering committee and additional experts, participated in the consensus process and voted on the proposed recommendations. Given the need to coordinate multiple experts across geographies and ensure timely completion of each stage, effective coordination and timeline management were critical to the success of the project. Turacoz facilitated this process by coordinating expert meetings, administering the online voting process, and systematically collating the responses.

What Challenges Did the Consensus Process Face?

Due to the clinical heterogeneity of SCD and the diverse backgrounds and healthcare settings represented by the experts, achieving agreement on standardized recommendations presented a significant challenge. Following the first round of voting, the steering committee carefully reviewed the areas of disagreement and refined the recommendations to incorporate relevant perspectives from the expert panel. The modified recommendations were subsequently subjected to another round of voting, after which consensus was achieved.

Key Insights: What Did the Consensus Recommend?

The Impact

This initiative established the first international consensus recommendations for standardizing SCD clinical trial endpoints. This framework significantly enhances the design, interpretation, and reproducibility of future trials by guiding investigators, regulators, and the pharmaceutical industry in selecting clinically meaningful endpoints.

Client Outcome

With Turacoz’s medical writing and strategic communication support, the consensus manuscript has been accepted for publication in The Lancet Haematology, providing a standardized framework to advance SCD research globally.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do sickle cell disease clinical trials need standardized endpoints?

Variability in endpoint selection and in the definitions of vaso-occlusive complications limits cross-trial comparability and the ability to demonstrate treatment efficacy. Standardized endpoints and definitions support more consistent trial design, interpretation, and comparison across studies.

What is the difference between VOPC and VOEps?

In the consensus, VOPC is reserved strictly for acute pain crises, whereas VOEps is the broader term that also covers non-pain vaso-occlusive complications.

What inclusion criteria did the consensus recommend for VOEps?

The consensus recommended standardized trial inclusion criteria of at least 2 and no more than 12 VOEps per year.

What hemoglobin increase was considered clinically meaningful?

An increase of ≥1 g/dL in hemoglobin was defined as clinically meaningful. The consensus also proposed distinct hemoglobin correction targets for acute versus chronic anemia.

How did Turacoz support the Delphi consensus and publication?

Turacoz conducted the evidence review, developed an evidence deck, coordinated expert meetings, administered the online voting, collated responses, developed the manuscript, and supported journal submission and peer-review revisions, leading to the manuscript’s acceptance for publication in The Lancet Haematology.

Planning a Delphi Consensus or a High-Impact Journal Publication?

Talk to the Turacoz team about publication writing, publication management, and submission support for consensus statements and journal manuscripts. Contact us: https://turacoz.com/contact-us/

References

  1. Vichinsky E, Hoppe CC, Ataga KI, Ware RE, Nduba V, El-Beshlawy A, et al. A phase 3 randomized trial of voxelotor in sickle cell disease. N Engl J Med. 2019;381(6):509–19.
  2. Crizanlizumab with or without hydroxyurea in patients with sickle cell disease (STAND): primary analyses from a placebo-controlled, randomised, double-blind, phase 3 trial.

    Author :

    Dr Sucharita Das 

    Senior Medical Writer 

    Medical Services, Turacoz Healthcare Solutions

    About the author: 

    Dr. Sucharita is a Senior Medical Writer at Turacoz Healthcare Solutions with more than two years of experience in developing advisory board deliverables, drafting consensus manuscripts, and creating web-based encyclopedia content. She has hands-on experience supporting projects across the European and Middle Eastern markets, contributing to the development of high-quality, evidence-based scientific communications customized to regional healthcare needs. 

    You Might Also Like

    • Overcoming publication challenges for a client’s manuscript

      Client: Dr. XXX, a leading researcher in cardiovascular medicine

    • Translating medical documents into regional Spanish for a pharma client

      Turacoz, a renowned medical writing and healthcare communications company, has a strong reputation for delivering high-quality, accurate, and culturally sensitive medical

    • Transforming adboard meeting dynamics

      In the rapidly evolving landscape of healthcare, effective communication is paramount to drive innovation, shape strategies, and foster collaborations. Turacoz

    • Developing a therapeutic docket from clinical trial findings

      In the dynamic landscape of pharmaceuticals and healthcare, the dissemination of clinical trial data to healthcare providers (HCPs) plays a

    • Elevating scientific integrity: a case study on addressing comments and annotations in eDetail Aid development

      Client: Pharma Target Audience: Healthcare Professionals (HCPs) Overview: The eDetail Aid serves as a critical tool in pharmaceutical communication, bridging

    • Developing an HIV training module in slide deck format for a pharma client client: pharma

      Client: Pharma Target Audience: Medical Affairs Internal Team The landscape of HIV treatment is continually evolving as new clinical studies and

    • Driving engagement and education in healthcare through podcast series

      Navigating the dynamic landscape of pharmaceutical marketing requires agility and innovation. Turacoz Healthcare Solutions prides itself on being at the

    • Successful adaptation and creation of a localized labelling for an ophthalmology product in a novel market: a case study

      With the evolution of the pharmaceutical industry (Pharmaceutical Solutions), expanding into new markets presents both opportunities and challenges for companies

    • Overcoming document recreation challenges in pharma medical writing

      In the ever-evolving landscape of medical writing, challenges frequently emerge that demand innovative solutions and meticulous attention to detail. This

    • Empowering leadership through strategic content: a comprehensive case Study of Turacoz’s empowerment day video for pharma leadership management

      In response to an urgent request from a prominent pharmaceutical client, Turacoz, a leading Medical Writing Agency and Medical Communications Services provider,

    • Transformative Journey in medical communication: a comprehensive case study

      In the dynamic landscape of healthcare, effective communication is paramount for disseminating critical information. This case study explores the transformative

    • Transforming pharma engagement: a case study in medico-marketing asset development

    • Documentation of periodic safety update report

      Objective: To train and mentor the doctors on the good medical writing practices and address their publication related challenges.

    • Medical writing workshop for doctors in Dubai

      Objective: To train and mentor the doctors on the good medical writing practices and address their publication related challenges.

    • Scripting of Meta-analyses

      Objective: The client approached us with a challenging project that required the development of meta-analysis on the effect of phenobarbit

    • Documentation of clinical study reports

      Objective: The client approached us to develop the CSR for a phase 1 trial (therapeutic area: bone disorder). It was

    • Conducting survey on antifungal medication

      Objective: The client (a leading pharmaceutical company) approached us with a project that required conducting a survey with the doctors.

    • Development of medical rationale document

      Objective: The client specified that they required an intensive Medical Rationale Document (MRD) to be developed for a global study

    • End-to-end publication support

      Objective: The client approached us with a manuscript writing project which required drafting the manuscript, getting the same approved from

    • Coverage of advisory board meetings and development of consensus statement

      Objective: The client approached us with a challenging project that required the generation of consensus statement for prophylactic management of

    • Training for nephrologists consultants and postgraduate students

      Objective: A assignment required us to train a group of nephrology consultants on various key aspects of medical writing. The

    • From a Single Survey to a 360° Evidence Story

      A medical communications case study: turning HCP survey data into publication, detailing, and field engagement content A leading dermatology brand

    • From Research to Publication: How We Helped 260 Faculty Members and Students Publish With Confidence 

      The Challenge  An NAAC Grade A medical university, accredited by NABH and NMC, in Nashik approached us with a real

    • Defending the Value of Standard-Dose Influenza Vaccination in a Changing European Market: A Medical Communications Case Study

      As influenza vaccine technologies evolved, high-dose and recombinant vaccines increasingly challenged the established role of standard-dose influenza vaccines, particularly among

    Newsletter

    Subscribe to our newsletter and get informed about the latest trends, insights, and updates in medical communications.

    partner with us

    Partner with Turacoz to bring science to life through strategic and evidence-based communication.

    Partner with Us